Homemade Greek Yogurt | Instant Pot, Slow Cooker, Oven, and Countertop Methods

Have you ever thought about making your own homemade Greek yogurt from scratch? If not, you definitely need to give it a try. This recipe is so simple, you'll wonder why you've never made it this way before!

Why Make Yogurt At Home?

When you can buy yogurt at the store for very little money, why bother making your own homemade Greek yogurt? Here are a few reasons why people like home-made yogurt.

• No additives. No need to add sugar, gum, gelatin, or other additives. Milk. Yogurt starter. Done.
• Choice of milk. Whole milk, 2% milk, skim milk, goat milk, sheeps milk, or even yogurt made with half and half--all of this is possible with Homemade Yogurt.
• Non-dairy milk yogurt. With a little know-how, you can make almond milk yogurt, soy milk yogurt, or coconut milk yogurt. If you want a dairy-free yogurt, making it at home is a fine way to do it.
• Mild or Tart. The longer you let it incubate, the more tart your yogurt. Usually, it sets in about 8 hours. If you let it keep incubating for 12 hours, you will have a very tart yogurt. So you have some control over the final product.
• Flavorings and sweetness of choice. Many people like plain yogurt. Some of us like cardamom yogurt, or Vietnamese sweet yogurt. Some want to use a keto sweetener. When making yogurt at home it's easy to make any variation you prefer.
• Sense of accomplishment. Honestly, this alone is reason enough to do it. It's easy. It's fun. Your kids will love doing it with you.

The creamy consistency of homemade Greek yogurt can be used in a variety of recipes, or you can simply add it to your morning smoothie or enjoy it by itself with some fruit, coconut and nuts garnished on top – the possibilities are truly endless!

Different Ways to Make Homemade Yogurt

Here are some of the common ways if which you can make homemade greek yogurt.

• Instant Pot yogurt.
• Slow Cooker yogurt.
• Making yogurt in the Oven
• Making yogurt on the Countertop.

What do all these methods have in common? The basic process is the same.

How to Make Yogurt

• Heat milk for 2 minutes in the microwave and test with your pinky finger. It should feel just ever so slightly warmer than your skin temperature but not burn you. If you've ever warmed up milk for a baby bottle, you know how this feels--you want it just a tad warmer than that.
• Don't overheat. You're aiming for about 105F-110F on the temperature.
  • Do not use very hot milk to make the best Greek yogurt. Anything over 115F will kill all the starter bacteria and you will have milk, not yogurt when you are done.
  • I know most Instant Pot recipes ask you to heat to 180F on the yogurt setting and then cool it down to 110F. This takes forever!
  • Since I'm all about #ruthlessefficiency I start with UHT milk, which has previously been heated and I skip this step.
• Mix milk with a starter. I like to use 2-3 tablespoons of yogurt for every 8 cups of milk. Pour a little of the warm milk into your starter and mix until it's well dissolved. (Buy a small 8 oz cup of plain greek yogurt and use this as your starter.) Pour this mixture into your warm milk and mix once again.
• Choose your method.
  • Instant Pot Yogurt. You can use the yogurt setting on your Instant Pot and let the yogurt incubate for 8-12 hours.
  • Slow Cooker Yogurt. You can put the milk into a warmed slow cooker. Turn the slow cooker on low for 30 minutes and then turn it off. Place the milk-yogurt mixture into the crockpot. Wrap it with a towel to retain the heat, and let it sit overnight.
  • Oven 1. Turn on the starter light in the oven. Place the milk-yogurt mixture in the oven, and let it sit overnight.
  • Oven 2. Turn oven to 250F. When it reaches that temperature, turn it off. Place the milk-yogurt mixture in the oven, and let it sit overnight.
  • Countertop Yogurt. So you don't actually need any appliances to make yogurt. I grew up making yogurt every might at home. We simply placed the milk yogurt mixture on the countertop, and we let it incubate overnight. If you live in a cold climate, it may take longer. But at 73F house, your yogurt will set with no help from any appliance.
• Chill. Place the yogurt in the fridge overnight. This helps the yogurt set properly without getting tart, and it gets thicker.
• Drain. Once the yogurt is set, you want to strain out the whey if you want homemade Greek Yogurt, or you can eat it as it is.
  • You can use cheesecloth or a large coffee filter in a large stainless strainer, place the strainer over a bowl and let it drip in the fridge overnight.
  • Alternatively, you can buy a Cuispro Donvier yogurt maker which is easier to clean up. For larger quantities of yogurt, a Eurocuisine Greek Yogurt Maker works better.
• Sweeten or flavor. I find it best to sweeten the yogurt after it is drained so you're not draining your lovely honey down the drain. You can use honey, agave, or a keto-friendly sweetener. You could also consider adding sugar-free syrups.

And there you have it. Lovely, homemade Greek yogurt.

What is Cold Start Yogurt?

Cold Start Yogurt is when you start with room temperature milk and place it in the Instant Pot. You skip the whole first step of heating the milk, then cooling the milk, so it also referred to as the No-Boil Method.

Does it work? Absolutely it does. When I first shared my cold start method with Fairlife milk 3 years ago, I got a lot of push back on the safety of this method. Since Indians have been making it in this way for centuries, I wasn't that worried 🙂

The video in this post shows you how to make cold start yogurt in your Instant Pot. Find the directions and video for how to make Instant Pot Hot Start Yogurt here.

Why heat the milk to 180F to make yogurt?

This is the perfect way to make your yogurt if you do not want to deal with boiling milk or straining

Many people believe that you get thicker yogurt from doing this. When you heat milk, the protein in milk denatures. This denatured protein intertwines with the casein from the yogurt, and creates a thicker yogurt.

Here's what I have found. If you use UHT milk, you can skip the heating step, and still get very thick yogurt. If you use UHT Ultra-Filtered milk like Fairlife, you can get excellent yogurt.

Who knew yogurt could be so complex yet so easy and satisfying at the same time?

How to Make Non-Dairy Yogurt

You can use almond, coconut, cashew, hemp, and soy milk to make non-dairy yogurt.

You will need one of two things to make nondairy yogurt: either a thickener like agar agar or gelatin, and/or lactobacillus tablets.

In my cardamom yogurt recipe, I used gelatin to provide a little thickening.

• Thick Milk. Use the thickest version of the milk you can find. For example, for coconut yogurt use full-fat canned coconut milk, not the watery stuff in cartons.
• Ratios. For every 4 cups of nondairy milk, use 1 tablespoon of gelatin and 1 teaspoon probiotic powder.
• Long ferment cycle. Prepare to allow the yogurt to ferment for 12-18 hours.
• Vegan Starter Kits. Alternatively, you can purchase a vegan yogurt starter kit like this one.

Troubleshooting Homemade Yogurt

Can I be honest? People in the Instant Pot Community WAY overthink yogurt. It's not complicated! But if you've never made it before, you may have a few questions. So here's your troubleshooting guide with the most commonly asked questions about making yogurt

Looking for delicious Yogurt recipes? Look no further!

• 

• 

• 

• Indian Lassi
• Indian Yogurt Soup | Instant Pot Gluten-Free Indian Kadhi
• Borani Persian Yogurt Spinach Dip
• Instant Pot Indian Chicken Curry with Spinach & Yogurt
• Labneh Dip
• Cardamom Yogurt (Noosa style)
• Vietnamese Yogurt
• Mango Frozen Yogurt
• Saffron Scented Yogurt

Making homemade yogurt is fun, easy, delicious and way more nutritious than store-bought yogurt.

You can make homemade Greek yogurt plain or make it sweet, and it can be used in so many different ways. Give it a try the next time you are craving some yogurt - you surely will not be disappointed!

Don't forget to check out my other Best-selling Instant Pot Cookbooks!

Indian Instant Pot, Keto Instant Pot, Instant Pot Fast and Easy, Healthy Instant Pot & Vegetarian Instant Pot.